Really? Kiss of death Scotty? I’m sure you’re all over it NDN!
Scotty: I thought it was ok but not amazing this week. Just the opposite, I’d have Scotty do as traditional county as possible instead of trying to push him out of his comfort zone. That’s where he’ll hit it out of the park every time.
Samuel L Jackson is narrating a Disney movie? WOW that’s hilarious.
James: Wait, having a marching band drum line is contemporary? That **** hasn’t been cool since like the 1850’s. Plumes were NEVER cool! I know I was in marching band! The song was completely and utterly awesome. Yes, taking the last chorus up the octave was nuts. It’s kind of bad though that they pushed his performance up so early, it deserved better.
Wow the 2 worst contestants left hate each other. Odd, you’d think they’d be together.
Haley: Yeah she’s still terrible. She should sing the entire time with backup singers, they cover up how bad she is. Kind of like you drench cheap liquor in soda so you can’t taste how terrible it is.
Jacob: That song was moving I’m very impressed. I’m not sure what happened at the beginning, but I quickly forgot about it as I got in the song with him. I don’t think I agree with the comments about restraining his range, he needs to do that in order to connect with the audience as he did.
I’m not sure if Maroon 5 is more or less epic than my suggestion of having Casey do Lady Gaga.
Casey: Continues to be epic. This week he was even relevant too! OH WOW I did not expect him to just walk right to J-Lo and kiss her. He drove Randy and Steven to swearing and Ryan to wearing a beard! No one can possibly top that.
Stefano: It honestly wasn’t that bad. He did get a chance to put something in his wheelhouse. He’s still a cut below the rest of the field in my mind, and should have been gone a long time ago.
Also, Stefano totally sounded like a douche in the exit interview
Lauren: God damn it why the hell are they giving her the pimp spot? She’s deserved to be in the bottom 3 for god knows how long but people keep voting for her! So they are going to pimp her for more votes?!?!
It wasn’t too bad again, but she just will never hit the level of Casey or James or Scotty in my mind. I didn’t notice any glaring flaws in her performance though, I just didn’t think it was awesome, or moving, or impressive.
Winner: Casey. Because no one has come close to having a moment like that on the idol stage in years
My bottom 3: Stefano, Haley, and [this spot reserved for the loser of run off between Scotty and Lauren]
America’s Bottom 3: Stefano, Haley, Scotty
Scotty was kiss of death-ed and had kind of a weak week, so I think he ends up in the bottom 3, with Stefano and Haley, the 2 who are obviously weaker than everyone else.
Going home: Haley