American Idol - Season 10

[klinkman]

Jacob was pretty good there to be honest. Maybe anyone would have looked good following Haley. It's still clear that he pales to the top of this competition, but hopefully he'll be out of the bottom 3 this week. I count 4 so far that are significantly worse.

[klinkman]

Well, I shouldn't have expected anything less from James. He rocked it hard. It might be good that he got the pimp spot, as a good chunk of America just won't vote for a metal singer. But he got votes when he did Judas Priest, this might not be any different.

[klinkman]

My bottom 3: Lauren, Stefano, Haley

Expected bottom 3: Paul, Lauren, Stefano

Going home: Stefano

Winner: James-He got to do the song he wanted, in the pimp spot, and nail it hard.

[taylovesthebeatles]

Correction to my bottom 3: Stefano Haley Jacob

[NDN]

I'm too disappointed with this week's show to give a deep summary.

My Top 3 (In order from best to worst): Jacob, James, Casey (Haley is a close fourth).
My Bottom 3: Paul, Stefano, Scotty
America's Bottom 3: Stefano, Lauren, Paul
Going Home: Stefano

I like the advice Jimmy is giving to people. It's honest REAL advice from someone who knows what they are talking about. He's blunt and I think the contestants can use his input more so than anything any of the judges have said all season. Hell, what he did with Jacob tonight was absolutely amazing and Jacob is going to owe him his life for extending his time on AI. At the end of the day I want the contestants to be who they are (Casey & James made the right decision with their songs), but at least Jimmy is giving them advice from a perspective that matters.

[Ringo]

Paul sounded like a seal arg arg arg
Lauren is too busy partying every night with her new boyfriend star of Twilight to even be taken serious. She's only 16 and her mother lets her party and date Hollywood stars. Shame on that country girl
"you move me beyond tears" REALLY STEVEN REALLY quit fawning over her already you perve.
Stefano: Worst shirt award, what the hell is he spending his $400 a week wardrobe money on? Terrible song choice and I didn't see any performance ROFLMOA
Scotty: I never heard that song before and it bored me stiff and then Randy (bless his big mouth) gave Scotty the curse saying that a star was born on AI stage.
Archeletta same thing, Adam Lambert same thing, Crystal Bowersock same thing.
Thank you Randy
The judges put no pressure on Scotty to do anything other than sing country ballads unlike previous years the contestants are forced to change it up or feel the rath of Simon
Casey the Beatnick that just doesn't fit the hollywood mold but he is trying real hard to change that. I love Nat king Cole but I had never heard that song and I don't believe America took any interest at all in his style of Jazz singing.
Hailey: She shouted a bit to much but I liked the song choice and I did watch her twice. Mad at the judges for dissing her so hard when they praised everyone else in the show but her. BITE ME JUDGES
Jacob: before song looked and acted like he had lost his best friend and then he sings the most depressing song and version of a depressing song I have ever heard (shocked that NDN liked it the best)
He has given up on the compitition> it just proves that you don't want to pull the feather out of a *** mans hat.
James: That's more like it, not his best vocals but he out-performed everyone combined. that a boy James I loved it.

American Idol keeps allowing multiple voting options so they can keep fooling us with record number of votes and now it has backfired on them with Pia getting voted off last week. The talk now is to change voting to 1 vote per household or phone #. That will never happen because the numbers would drop drastactly. Ryan would say this week we got a new
voting process record # of votes with 12 million votes,,,NOT 64 million like they claim they get a week
They have gone cheap this year by not hiring any mentors and my suggestion is even go cheaper next year and can all the judges and just push a mic in front of an audience member,
Could enjoy a few viral monents!!!!

Sorry I sound a little negative today. I would feel better if they would vote off the entire bottom 3 tonight
They know who they are:

Stefano, Jacob and Paul
of the 3 I would not like to ever hear sing again????????????????????????????????????????????? ?????????????????????????????
all three and Lauren

[NDN]

Jacob: before song looked and acted like he had lost his best friend and then he sings the most depressing song and version of a depressing song I have ever heard (shocked that NDN liked it the best)
He has given up on the compitition> it just proves that you don't want to pull the feather out of a *** mans hat.

You have to give credit where credit is due. In what turned out to be a second straight week of boring performances, Jacob was definitely the best of the group. That doesn't mean I am going to go back and watch his performance again, and I still think he falls into the same category as Paul with regards to being the same each week, but at least he sounded good.

[NDN]

The results are in and I think America got one right tonight.

The bottom three were: Stefano, Haley, Paul

The person going home is:

Spoiler

Paul