American Idol - Season 10

[NDN]

It's that time of week again, so here are my thoughts on tonight's show.

Overall, I find myself more confused than ever before as to where to place each contestant. James was the stand-out of the night, but I think the other five were all really close this week. I was actually more entertained tonight than I thought I would be with the songs of Carole King.

James: This was a fantastic effort. I only wish he would have had the balls to do the entire song without music because that first part was unbelievable and I wouldn't have had any problems listening to an entire song like that.

Casey: This was great for what it was, but I'm not sure it's what I was looking for tonight. I certainly can't criticize any of it (loved the piano at the start) but I can't put it at the top of my favorite Casey moments.

Haley: This wasn't anywhere near the best she's been, but I hope America will agree that it was good enough to keep her around. It seems like even with a not so great performance a lot more people are rooting for her than ever before. At least that's the impression I got (that was echoed by the Judge's comments too).

Scotty: This was my favorite Scotty performance (granted that's not saying much). I think he showed more range than ever before and FINALLY one of his songs sounded different than the same thing he's done up until now. If he can grow and keep pushing himself, I might have a harder time giving him so much ****.

Lauren: This wasn't great and it wasn't horrible. Unfortunately, I don't think that does much for her at this point in the competition. If she lasts another week, she better really go for it!

Jacob: Again, not great and not horrible. Unfortunately, I think he has worn out his welcome a little more than Lauren has and think he'll get the boot this week.

Bottom Three: Jacob, Lauren, Haley
Going Home: Jacob

[NDN]

I forgot to mention the duets!

If duets count (and they aren't supposed to) then I put Haley higher up on my list tonight and not in the bottom three. Her duet with Casey was epic and was probably my favorite part of the show tonight.

The duet between Lauren and Scotty was forgettable (as were there other three this season).

I didn't like the duet between James and Jacob, but I did like that you actually got the impression that Jacob was finally having genuine FUN!

[Ringo]

First off I wish Jimmy would lose the hat
mad at AI for matching up Lauren and Scotty for the 3rd time for their duet which Lauren totally creamed Scotty.
Casey and Haley teamed up again wasn't fair either.
However James and Lusky sounded great. It was corny as hell and FU Steven for dissing them, but there were some great sounding moments in their duet and James made some great Elvis moves. Did you hear those two match those high notes perfectly togther. Awesome. Go back and watch again.

Jacob- has a fantastic voice but sang a forgettable song
Scotty- started out sounding country but lost it several times during his song
Lauren- sounds great but all too country is getting old
James- had another star moment this week James 2- Scotty-0
Casey- I loved this performance and even though he is such a goof off on stage, Casey is 10 times more entertaining than Scotty
Haley- Bad song choice and it bored me

Have to thank AI actually after more thought, putting James and Jacob together. When Jacob gets the boot tonight, his fan base will now support James. I was already counting on this to happen, while the country vote will go to Lauren now and the tween vote to Scotty now fading.
Should be close thanks to the producers who are getting sick of Scotty being a smart *** and not listening to them.
Best quote of the night: Lauren " Scotty never compliments me!"
FNPOSAW he is.

[NDN]

Just finished watching the results show and I am quite disappointed.

They sent Casey home tonight and it's a crying shame! He was one of my favorites on the show and he was extremely talented. I looked forward to seeing his performance each and every week.

I don't get excited about watching Jacob, Lauren, or Scotty each week, so I really hope it comes down to James and Haley at the end or I might quit watching.

As everyone pointed out in this thread, I think Casey lost it for himself. The song last night wasn't going to appeal to the masses and that's why he went home tonight.

On a semi-related note, I watched The Voice tonight and I quite enjoyed it. For the first show I think they did a great job and I think this one has some potential! I have to see how the next "round" after the "blind auditions" goes before I can say I am officially on board though.

[nodepositneeded]

So who do you guys think will win ?

[NDN]

Someone undeserving of the title; that's for sure!

This year started off so promising and then got worse nearly every week!

Haley certainly should have taken the title between the final three. Scotty & Lauren are so weak compared to some greats that were voted off (Casey, James, Pia to name a few).

[diablodawg]

I never watchd idol,but hear and know everything bout it,my wife is an idol junkie yes i said JUNK ee.