American Idol - Season 10

[eejit101]

Brit. not Brett. As in simon cowell

[taylovesthebeatles]

Brit. not Brett. As in simon cowell

I know, I was referring to NDN saying that Brett was in his top 5 guys.

[NDN]

Brett was a random pick. Casey, Jacob, Paul, and Stefano were easy locks for me, but the other eight were all extremely horrible. I went with Brett because although his performance was creepy, there were parts where I thought the voice had some potential with better song selection.

As for Scotty, unlike you I do love country music, yet his voice did nothing for me.

I'm surprised to hear you liked the guys better and I'd be interested to hear from other members who watch the show.

I thought the girls I picked were absolutely amazing. I'll throw you a bone and say Naima could get a judges pick because of her uniqueness and I did hear some hints of a voice in her marginal performance.

Tay, maybe you fall into that young female voting crowd I mentioned and thus you're partial to the guys?!?!

[klinkman]

Brett was a random pick. Casey, Jacob, Paul, and Stefano were easy locks for me, but the other eight were all extremely horrible. I went with Brett because although his performance was creepy, there were parts where I thought the voice had some potential with better song selection.

As for Scotty, unlike you I do love country music, yet his voice did nothing for me.

I'm surprised to hear you liked the guys better and I'd be interested to hear from other members who watch the show.

I thought the girls I picked were absolutely amazing. I'll throw you a bone and say Naima could get a judges pick because of her uniqueness and I did hear some hints of a voice in her marginal performance.

Tay, maybe you fall into that young female voting crowd I mentioned and thus you're partial to the guys?!?!

Stefano is an easy lock all right....easy lock for "Worst American Idol performance this season"

God he was terrible. I seriously hope you were trolling us.

[NDN]

Stefano is an easy lock all right....easy lock for "Worst American Idol performance this season"

God he was terrible. I seriously hope you were trolling us.

Don't let your dislike for the genre he sang dissuade you from the vocals.

[klinkman]

Don't let your dislike for the genre he sang dissuade you from the vocals.

Were you watching the same Stephano I was watching? Are you sure? That dude could not sing.

I didn't let my dislike of country prevent me from voting for Scotty. Or my dislike of Judas Priest prevent me from voting for James...Stephano just SUCKED. He was off pitch or undersinging the entire time, the song wasn't enjoyable to listen to, quite the opposite it was grating on the ears. You have GOT to be confusing Stephano with someone else..that's the only explanation other than you're completely deaf!

[NDN]

Were you watching the same Stephano I was watching? Are you sure? That dude could not sing.

I didn't let my dislike of country prevent me from voting for Scotty. Or my dislike of Judas Priest prevent me from voting for James...Stephano just SUCKED. He was off pitch or undersinging the entire time, the song wasn't enjoyable to listen to, quite the opposite it was grating on the ears. You have GOT to be confusing Stephano with someone else..that's the only explanation other than you're completely deaf!

I think you're letting Tay influence your opinions. Show those true colors Klinkman; we want to know what YOU thought!

[taylovesthebeatles]

Tay, maybe you fall into that young female voting crowd I mentioned and thus you're partial to the guys?!?!

Far from it, I was actually hoping that there was a pretty lady I could get behind, and there just wasn't. In any sense.

[NDN]

Far from it, I was actually hoping that there was a pretty lady I could get behind, and there just wasn't. In any sense.

Sounds like someone is in denial for being part of the stereotypical AI voter group!