Yes it would be, but he's not going to call with A9 off suit. He was trying to steal the blinds from early position and was hoping for no resistance. Second off, when you bet on the flop, how does he call chasing a gut shot? Your re-raise didn't scream strength it screamed I'm trying to buy this pot more than you. Now, from his point of view, you have position and could have something like KQ suited, where he is ahead.

If he does call, he's not going to lead out with a bet with that flop and expect to pick up the pot, therefore he's not going to cripple himself with a bad play. Now when you bet, he's going to fold 80% of the time. The other 20% he's going to call and you are a huge favorite.

By pushing all in preflop you are taking away any advantage position offered you. Hell, if you just call, you can make a bet/raise on the turn based on his action. Now you have announced to the whole table that you know your hand is better and that he is trying to steal. You pick up the pot there too.

The biggest fact I'm trying to convey is don't give the power of position when you can use it to your advantage. There are many ways to play this hand where you have chips on the flop and can use them to your advantage with the best position. You chose the 1 way that took position out of the equation and left it up to chance. If that's how you want to play, great, but don't ***** when someone sucks out on you. After all, you allowed them to by not using position to your advantage.

And yes, I read your entire post twice to make sure I understood it before I submitted my first response. As a tip, post the history from the site, not your version of what happened. It makes it much easier to see exactly what happened.