American Idol - Season 10

[NDN]

I would get involved in this discussion as well, but I know you'd just be convinced we were colluding, and not actually just sharing a brain and agreeing on the merits of musical talent. One thing that should make you feel better though, is that I like Paul far more than he does.

Glad to hear you know your place!

Just kidding of course! Jump on in! I can handle the two of yas!

We need a female opinion or two (although I think we may be getting that from klinkwoman... I mean klinkman).

[PANAMHIEST]

ok im gonna give out my early vote of the winner now. I think it is gonna be jacob. I dont have a expert opinion, i just feel the music when he is on stage. It seems real and it hits you even if it isnt the best vocals. If not him, then james for the same reasons.

[NDN]

What did you feel when he sang "I Believe I Can Fly" the other night?

[PANAMHIEST]

What did you feel when he sang "I Believe I Can Fly" the other night?

like he could of done alot better, and i think he will going forward

[NDN]

like he could of done alot better, and i think he will going forward

I'm sure he will too. Although, one more night like Tuesday and he'll be gone with only himself to blame.

[Ringo]

I like the Pied Piper Paul. He could get the whole country dancing.

Shame Ashton left last night, she had alot of talent, but she has alot of growing up to do.
Thia will not make it very far either, too young.

[NDN]

I feel the complete opposite. I was happy to see Ashton go; she was certainly deserving of it.

It's interesting to see the polar opposite opinions some of us have with regards to some of the contestants.