American Idol - Season 10

[klinkman]

Is this like last night's Conan where the West Coast got 30 minutes of commercials and a screwed up show, but it only happened for NDN? That's the only explanation for his post...

[NDN]

Is this like last night's Conan where the West Coast got 30 minutes of commercials and a screwed up show, but it only happened for NDN? That's the only explanation for his post...

That gives us a little more insight as to why our opinions differ so greatly. I say that because I absolutely despise Conan (have never liked him on any platform) and I have learned over the years that there are some big differences between people who like Conan and people who hate Conan (and there is no middle ground).

[Ringo]

Project Free TV :: American Idol

for those who still pay through the nose for TV

Lusky- reminds me of a small child hugging his favorite stuffed animal/ vote total way down
Haley- her popularity is rising but no where near the top 3
Jacob- ZzzzzZzzzz his "revolutionary" Bass got all the props, while his voice died and so did his vote total
Lauren- Boring Karaoke performance- totally forgettable and so is she
James- was OK wish he had sang that song 1 key lower with abit of a scratchy voice, his tears
leaped him into the top 3 again
Scotty: I will say it again, My wife gets titilated everytime she sees him and I actually liked his performance when I closed my eyes and didn't have to watch his silly face and hand movements. My wife says, "Girls, love that stuff" CHRIST THE DECK IS STACKED
Now I know why my dad hated Elvis when he was young, because all the girls loved him.
Pia: Horns in the background are terrible and drown out alot of vocals, the judges praises are keeping her in the Top 3, funny thing is that I can't get that damned huge song out of my head, Disney is going to love her singing all the animated soundtracks
Stephano: finally takes off his sneakers lol The song OWNED HIM and he sounded the same as he has every week
Paul: ruined a great Johnny Cash song for me, too fast paced and too weird of a voice with no lower register 'perfect imperfect boy" said Steven I want to throw up

overall NDN hit on the head, this show was soooo BORING
I only saw 3 songs changed up alittle from the originals and the judges didn't critisize anyone because of it.

I have been to better Karaoke nights locally.

DialIdol has Scotty getting 11 mil votes followed by James with 9 mil and Pia with 7 mil and everone else with 3 mil and fewer

It's a 3 horse race now and Pia will fade early in the stretch with her lack of " IT FACTOR" and James will fade at the finish while scotty wins never breaking a sweat laughing all the way.

[NDN]

overall NDN hit on the head, this show was soooo BORING
I only saw 3 songs changed up alittle from the originals and the judges didn't critisize anyone because of it.

You make a great point there. The judges had nothing but great things to say about every performance and I was baffled by that because it was such a weak night of American Idol.

[taylovesthebeatles]

Project Free TV :: American Idol

for those who still pay through the nose for TV

Lusky- reminds me of a small child hugging his favorite stuffed animal/ vote total way down
Haley- her popularity is rising but no where near the top 3
Jacob- ZzzzzZzzzz his "revolutionary" Bass got all the props, while his voice died and so did his vote total
Lauren- Boring Karaoke performance- totally forgettable and so is she
James- was OK wish he had sang that song 1 key lower with abit of a scratchy voice, his tears
leaped him into the top 3 again
Scotty: I will say it again, My wife gets titilated everytime she sees him and I actually liked his performance when I closed my eyes and didn't have to watch his silly face and hand movements. My wife says, "Girls, love that stuff" CHRIST THE DECK IS STACKED
Now I know why my dad hated Elvis when he was young, because all the girls loved him.
Pia: Horns in the background are terrible and drown out alot of vocals, the judges praises are keeping her in the Top 3, funny thing is that I can't get that damned huge song out of my head, Disney is going to love her singing all the animated soundtracks
Stephano: finally takes off his sneakers lol The song OWNED HIM and he sounded the same as he has every week
Paul: ruined a great Johnny Cash song for me, too fast paced and too weird of a voice with no lower register 'perfect imperfect boy" said Steven I want to throw up

overall NDN hit on the head, this show was soooo BORING
I only saw 3 songs changed up alittle from the originals and the judges didn't critisize anyone because of it.

I have been to better Karaoke nights locally.

DialIdol has Scotty getting 11 mil votes followed by James with 9 mil and Pia with 7 mil and everone else with 3 mil and fewer

It's a 3 horse race now and Pia will fade early in the stretch with her lack of " IT FACTOR" and James will fade at the finish while scotty wins never breaking a sweat laughing all the way.

Two points: CASEY played the bass, not Jacob, and did a mighty fine job of it, and Paul's rendition was not too fast, it was just right.